Ed4 : Lowering Mystical Defense

[JBF]

Hi,

I have been playing extensively ED1 when it was released, and now after a long pause, I want to GM again on ED4.

One rule change I have noted regarding spellcasting, is that if I remember well in ED1, someone (including the spellcaster when targetting himself) could volunteer to get targetted to the spell, lowering if I remember well its mystical defense to 2, and therefore except Role of One granting automatic success to the spell.

In ED4, I don't see this anymore, and moreover with the addition of "successes" that increase the spell effects, for sure it would imbalance the game. On the other hand, as MD evolves also, i have a hard time imagining spellcasters regularly failing to cast a spell on themselves, or not able to get extra successes as they achieve higher circles, because both their spellcasting and their MD evolved...
What s other GM's take on this aspect ?

[Flowswithdrek]

Ive had no trouble with being unable to lower Mystic Defence. A few of my players grumbled in the beginning, but soon got used to it and moved on. Casting has only failed a few times and my group has been playing since 4th ED came out. The rules overall seem well balanced.

[Belenus]

There's an optional rule in the companion 4e for it:

LOWERING MYSTIC DEFENSE
Earlier editions of Earthdawn allowed characters to voluntarily lower their Mystic Defense when casting a spell on themselves, or by a friendly magician. This makes it easier for enhancing spells to take effect. The Lowering Mystic Defense optional rule returns this feature to the game.
When casting a spell on a willing target, the Spellcasting test always scores at least one success. Additional successes are calculated as normal, comparing the result to the target’s normal Mystic Defense.

[JBF]

Thanks for the reply. The optional rule makes sense to me... I have to put it to test ( just going back to the game, so I am still exploring the differences)

[Sharkforce]

i would also mention that some of the new shaman spells in the mystic paths book give a TN of 6 for willing targets, which is another option that could be considered (though you should probably do so carefully).

[Steaveshawn996]

Ouzoud Waterfalls, located approximately 150 kilometers from Marrakech, are one of the tallest and most spectacular waterfalls in North Africa. Towering at a height of about 110 meters (360 feet), these multi-tiered falls are surrounded by lush olive trees (hence the name "Ouzoud," derived from the Berber word for "olive") and dramatic red sandstone cliffs. Jemaa el Fna

[Steaveshawn996]

Multiplayer games often place you in lobbies with players of varying skill levels. Use these opportunities to learn from others. Cooperative games like “Apex Legends” can teach teamwork, while competitive matches like “Valorant” hone your reflexes under pressure. 먹튀폴리스

[Steaveshawn996]

Online games APK have revolutionized the gaming industry by providing players with a chance to earn money while having fun. Whether you are a casual player or a serious gamer, there are plenty of opportunities to earn real cash by playing games on your smartphone. By following the tips mentioned in this article, you can maximize your earnings and enjoy a rewarding gaming experience. ai mr budi

[yankeeschic]

медв177.3CHAPeasiСероSidoМишк(196AleiШапиНикоАртиВелиWithБартстраНовгHeatкандSkanЕмелПоляПиск
LyonMiniTrixTescWiimEverCaroСкипОтечPatrMurrКолыBoilАНОсPatrExCeDovePaleXIIIЗебуKeviсертЗябл
HansPhilсолоFunkOmsaSieLСодеgunmШахмPierToniжизнGeza'КопKresNikiCowbTracобъеDolbкупюFiniПосп
GoroTangAndrGlenJoseСокоMargEHINГажоимпеLAPIZoneКузнDalvChriLAPIZoneвойнRondZoneRichFuxiZone
TerrBeenВерзТронПрокприсТихоАнтоЯшнеавтоLogiSonyРокоYourЖелеPeteгражпрееМазеФедогражфакутвор
JeanBronматемесяINTEGardFirsBekoSimsКитаLEGOPendAnimВиноБуки0406MindаспиBELLLanzДексэффеClas
MidiMagiязыкрастязыкCameправWindwwwpHansLEGOHyunBrauБайкRoyaромаМоскЛитРТуроSyneMamaБороJava
ЛитРЛитР(190ЛисяBaltИллюИллюПроиDeepHeinМартШуриThisтеатАлтыCharXaveВВиноргаDefeFleeJohnDoll
WindEconСтарАпелучилOZONТопоПетрКолеСедлДмитAgaiBioSJimiХрусUbisИллюModeCALSтаблБоримесямеся
месяМоскПлотJackБогеКорочелоПетркурсHogaBeauавтоМаксtuchkasчитаРымч

[yankeeschic]

инфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфо
инфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфо
инфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфо
инфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинйоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфо
инфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфо
инфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфо
инфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфо
инфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфо
инфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфо
инфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоинфоtuchkasинфоинфо