Search found 56 matches
- Tue Aug 12, 2014 5:11 pm
- Forum: Product Discussion
- Topic: Pre-art draft feedback
- Replies: 309
- Views: 137139
Re: Pre-art draft feedback
Archers have Call Missile and Air Sailors have Air Sailing but Sample characters got 9 Ranks spend on talents what looks weird comparing them to Scout (free Navigation) and Thief (free Danger Sense) - 8 Ranks spend. IMO, if Free Talents are really free magicians should have 10 Ranks spend (2 normal...
- Tue Aug 12, 2014 2:57 pm
- Forum: Product Discussion
- Topic: Pre-art draft feedback
- Replies: 309
- Views: 137139
Re: Pre-art draft feedback
I'm just about done with my proofread. I went over the Sample characters in the back of the book and found some oddities. Each one was done a little different. With that in mind I have a question about Free Talents. They go up with your Circle automatically. They don't count towards increasing Circl...
- Sun Aug 10, 2014 11:11 am
- Forum: Product Discussion
- Topic: Pre-art draft feedback
- Replies: 309
- Views: 137139
Re: Pre-art draft feedback
On delayed and reserved action pg 418. In gray sidebar it talks about the effects this has on talents. I follow the rules until after the example when this is written, "Likewise, if a character is able to use a talent or ability that relies on a higher Initiative, but chooses to delay or reserv...
- Sun Aug 10, 2014 1:04 am
- Forum: Product Discussion
- Topic: Pre-art draft feedback
- Replies: 309
- Views: 137139
Re: Pre-art draft feedback
Don't you think that Elemental Spear (Water) is too powerful? Healing targets during fight in such manner isn't too MMORPG style? Recovery Test granted by spell can be made as Free Action (what is second abuse IMO)? Can the caster target himself with such spear? It's almost two times better than Fi...
- Thu Aug 07, 2014 4:33 pm
- Forum: Product Discussion
- Topic: Pre-art draft feedback
- Replies: 309
- Views: 137139
Re: Pre-art draft feedback
I like the non armor defeating rules. Most players get more Good successes than excellent and now will be rewarded. That being said, how will this effect Thread Items powers? For example, Weapons that can defeat armor at Good success level for X Strain (Could not remember exact weapon or location), ...
- Thu Aug 07, 2014 2:24 pm
- Forum: Product Discussion
- Topic: Pre-art draft feedback
- Replies: 309
- Views: 137139
Re: Pre-art draft feedback
This really isn't a complaint, I'm wondering what the line of thinking that went into making magicians spend legend on spells. Seems like that will slow down their circle progression compared to the more martial disciplines. Thanks
- Wed Aug 06, 2014 8:35 am
- Forum: Product Discussion
- Topic: Pre-art draft feedback
- Replies: 309
- Views: 137139
Re: Pre-art draft feedback
I understand. I also know I'm in the minority. I've also gotten my fix since I'm reading the Preart. I just figured you could put out the PDF without page number references and update it later when you had both books done. I'll be happy either way. Thanks for all the hard work guys. I don't think it...
- Wed Aug 06, 2014 8:24 am
- Forum: Product Discussion
- Topic: GM's Guide -- Anything you would like to see?
- Replies: 223
- Views: 108579
Re: GM's Guide -- Anything you would like to see?
Mental stability would be good. Having a guideline on how to get from normal adept to horror crazy madman including how the effects of that translates to artisan skills and other facets of life
- Tue Aug 05, 2014 7:12 pm
- Forum: Product Discussion
- Topic: Pre-art draft feedback
- Replies: 309
- Views: 137139
Re: Pre-art draft feedback
Is the release of the gm guide going to coincide with the players guide so all the look at gm guide spots in the players guide will have specific page numbers. I know everyone wants the book ASAP but I think waiting a bit for a better product would be better. Can't really play without the gm book an...
- Tue Aug 05, 2014 2:29 pm
- Forum: Product Discussion
- Topic: Pre-art draft feedback
- Replies: 309
- Views: 137139
Re: Pre-art draft feedback
Once again I like that. I need to get out of 1st edition mindset and into 4th. Reread some rules; it's right there in black and white but I was reading thinking of discipline talents in 1st. Thanks.